INTERNET PIRACY - Protect Your Work & Yourself

In an era of widespread on-line piracy, there are many questions about how to:

  • Protect your work from unauthorized (uncompensated) copying, and
  • Protect yourself from liability for unauthorized use of works that are easily available on the Internet.
The Law

Historically, Copyright Law protected authors and their distributors. Copyright protects original works of authorship including artistic or literary work (from music and poetry to movies and computer software) for the life of the creator plus 70 years.

Copyright is a 'bundle of rights' including:
  • Reproduction
  • Adaptation
  • Distribution
  • Public performance
  • Public display
  • Digital performance of a sound recording
The law is evolving, but slowly.  In 1998, The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA) addressed who is liable for copyright infringement and disabling or circumventing protections of copyrighted materials.  It provides a safe harbor for ISPs (information service providers) redistributing copyright materials.

Another law called the Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act (UCITA) which is supported by publishers provides multiple mechanisms to control the use and further distribution of materials.  UCITA is controversial and has only been adopted in two states at this point.

Enabling v Blocking Technologies

Technologies are emerging that both enable and block the unauthorized use of creative content on the Internet.

Sophisticated file-sharing capability (like Napster), together with broadband communications, make copying and transmitting digital information easy.

Encryption and content scrambling systems ('CSS') are intended to block unauthorized use.

Protecting Your Work
  • Copying over the Internet is unstoppable.
  • Technology to halt piracy is expensive and likely to be circumvented.
Use business practices to protect your work.
  • Use copyright notices.
  • Clearly state 'All rights reserved' & 'Penalties for unauthorized use.'
  • Register your copyright.
Extensive information about how to register your copyright is available online on the Library of Congress web site.  Go to www.loc.gov, click on the Copyright Office section, and you'll have access to forms and information.

Use Contracts.
Contracts (formal and informal) can be an effective tool to protect your work and can range from a simple exchange of emails to a detailed agreement.

In your contract:
  • Specify what use is authorized.
    Authorized use can range from extremely limited, one-time use, to broad, for all media now known or hereafter created.
  • Specify terms and compensation for use and reuse.
    Fees can range from one-time fees, to per user, per transaction or subscription fees.  Collecting fees can be difficult, but the more clear you are about the fees that apply, the better your chances of getting paid.
Protecting Yourself

What's OK to copy?  You don't want to be sued for unauthorized use of someone else's work.

If you want to use a picture for promotional purposes, how can you determine if it's OK?

PUBLIC DOMAIN?
Just because a work is posted on the Internet does not mean it is in the public domain.  Works published before 1923 are in the public domain and are free to use.

FAIR USE?
The 'Fair use doctrine' of Copyright Law allows consumers to make and share limited copies of creative works for purposes such as educational, noncommercial, for parody or commentary.  Unfortunately, the 'fair use doctrine' is subject to interpretation.

REQUEST PERMISSION?
If in doubt, and your use is important to your business, request permission.  Requesting permission can be a simple email saying 'requesting permission to use (describe content) for (purpose).' Sometimes the copyright owner will say OK or request payment.  By requesting permission, at least you'll know if you have an issue, before you invest in that promotional piece.

In conclusion, the law is struggling to keep up with the changing technologies.  Legal battles rage in the Music and Entertainment industries, anti-piracy initiatives proliferate, and compensation models evolve.

Two things you can count on are:
  1. Technology will continue to advance, and
  2. Legal ambiguity will continue.
To reduce the risk of legal problems, stay informed, register your copyright and use contracts and notices.

Even in the Internet era, the old adage that 'an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure' is still good advice.

Jean D. Sifleet
Attorney & CPA

P.S. Do you know someone who might need my services?  If so, please forward this to their attention or point them to my Web site (www.smartfast.com) for more information.  I appreciate your referrals.

           

eNews Subscribe:
To subscribe, please fill out the form below.

Your email:

Jean Sifleet, business attorney, CPA and three-time entrepreneur, is pleased to announce the release of her new book, Advantage “IP”: Profit from Your Great Ideas. Visit the Smartfast Bookstore for details, and to order the book.

Information provided on this website is intended for a general overview and
should not be construed as legal advice for a particular situation.